Introduction

The correct usage of the word 'none' in a sentence can often lead to confusion. Is it correct to say 'none are getting by' or 'none is getting by'? This article delves into the nuances of this grammatical question, exploring the rules, examples, and reader feedback to provide clarity and context.

Understanding the Word 'None'

Definition of 'None': 'None' is an indefinite pronoun used to express the absence or lack of something. It can be used both as a singular or plural form, depending on the context and emphasis.

The Grammar Rules

The following points will help understand the correct usage of 'none' with respect to singular and plural verb forms.

1. Singular Usage of 'None'

When 'none' is used to denote a complete absence of something, it should typically be treated as a singular subject. In such cases, a singular verb should follow 'none'.

Example: None is getting by.

In this sentence, the verb 'is getting by' is singular, emphasizing that no one is managing to pass or succeed in a particular situation. This usage is generally more grammatically correct according to standard English grammar rules.

2. Plural Usage of 'None'

However, in certain contexts, 'none' might refer to a plural subject, emphasizing the lack of a specific group. In these cases, a plural verb is used.

Example: None of the students are getting by the test.

Here, the plural verb 'are getting by' is used to indicate that not one of the students in the group is managing to pass the test. This usage is more common in everyday speech and can be heard in practical scenarios.

Reader Feedback and Euphony

While the singular verb form ('none is getting by') is grammatically correct, it may not always sound natural to the ear. Reader feedback often supports the use of the plural verb form ('none are getting by'), which sounds more natural to many native English speakers.

Quote from a Google search result: 'I agree with using "none are getting by," as it flows better in conversational English. The singular form sounds awkward to me."

Some believe that in modern English, the preference for the plural verb form is driven by a desire for euphony, making the sentence sound more pleasing to the ear.

Conclusion

When using 'none' in a sentence, the choice between a singular or plural verb depends on the context and emphasis. If you want to focus on the complete absence of something, use the singular form ('none is getting by'). For emphasis on a group or its members, use the plural form ('none are getting by'). While the singular form might be more grammatically correct, the plural form is commonly accepted and often preferred in spoken English.

Ultimately, both forms can be correct, and the choice often hinges on what sounds most natural in a given context. As language evolves, it is important to consider both grammatical rules and the natural flow of speech when making these decisions.