The Naming of an Insurrection: How History and Symbolism Will Influence Our Terminology

As we reflect on the events of January 6, 2021, one question arises with particular significance: how will historians and contemporaries alike refer to this insurrection? The juxtaposition of a historical parallel, the Munich Beer Hall Putsch, sheds light on the complexity of naming such a pivotal event.

A Historical Parallel: The Munich Beer Hall Putsch

One of the closest historic parallels is the Munich Beer Hall Putsch, a failed Nazi uprising on November 8–9, 1923. Also known as the "Bierkeller Putsch" in German, this event was led by Adolf Hitler and Erich Ludendorff, who marched with around two thousand Nazis, from the Bürgerbr?ukeller in Haidhausen, in the direction of the Feldherrnhalle in the city center. Although they were met with force by armed police, the parallel is striking given the nature and setting of the January 6, 2021, Capitol insurrection.

A Proposed Name: "Ellipse Putsch"

Given the storming of the Capitol began near the Ellipse, a 52-acre park south of the White House fence and north of Constitution Avenue, some might suggest the term "Ellipse Putsch." This event, which involved a similar route from a vibrant public space to the heart of government, holds parallels with the historical Munich event. However, despite the parallels, the chosen name for this insurrection may not follow this logic.

Alternative Names: "Trump’s Folly" and "Trump’s Disgrace"

Given the central role of former President Donald Trump in inciting the insurrection, it's likely that the event may be referred to as either "Trump’s Folly" or "Trump’s Disgrace." These names emphasize the dishonorable and misguided nature of the actions undertaken. Both terms reflect the notion that the insurrection was a result of Trump's influence and leadership, highlighting the futility and disgrace associated with the events.

A Neutral Term: "Evidence"

Regardless of the choice of name, the insurrection will be recognized as a significant body of evidence. It provides a stark illustration of the dangers of conspiracy theories, populism, and government insubordination. Both the participants and observers will document this event as a crucial chapter in American history. The term "evidence" emphasizes the objective and factual nature of the incident, setting aside the emotional and political narrative that surrounds it.

Conclusion

While the insurrection of January 6, 2021, may be named "Trump’s Folly," "Trump’s Disgrace," or simply "evidence," it is clear that the labeling of this event will be a complex process. The choice of terms will reflect the societal, political, and emotional connotations of the insurrection, as well as the role of historical symbolism in shaping our understanding of such pivotal moments.