Is It Correct to Write 'They Is'? Debunking the Controversy

The English language is complex and constantly evolving. One such debate is whether it is grammatically correct to write 'they is' instead of 'they are'. This article delves into the nuances of English grammar, explores the use of they as a singular pronoun, and discusses the broader context of non-binary pronouns. Understanding these elements can help you write more effectively and respectfully.

The Grammar Behind Pronouns

In English, the pronoun they is traditionally considered plural. Yet, it is increasingly used to refer to a single person in a non-binary context, avoiding the gender binary of he or she. This usage is a response to the need for gender-inclusive language, a reflection of societal changes and the growing recognition of diverse gender identities.

The Evolution of Pronoun Usage

The use of they as a singular pronoun has been a gradual process. While the grammar textbooks may still mandate 'they is' for clarity, many writers and speakers are adopting more inclusive language. This shift is not just a matter of preference; it is a recognition of the evolving needs of a diverse and inclusive society.

Consistency and Clarity

Grammar rules serve to disambiguate language, ensuring that the subject and verb agree in number. Using they is can undermine this clarity, especially in complex sentences. For example, consider the sentence They is the best friend of everyone. Here, it is unclear whether they or everyone is the subject. On the other hand, They are the best friend of everyone. is straightforward and clear, as it is explicit about which person the verb belongs to.

While some argue that they is feels more natural when used in a non-binary context, the shift to they are maintains consistency and understanding. This consistency is crucial in written and spoken communication, where the intended meaning can often be lost without a clear subject-verb agreement.

The Controversy Surrounding 'They Is'

The debate over whether they is is grammatically correct is ongoing. Some linguists and prescriptive grammarians argue that grammar evolves over time, influenced by societal changes. However, others maintain the traditional view that they is is incorrect.

Two Sides of the Debate

1. Evolutionary Grammar: This perspective supports the use of they as a singular pronoun, especially in a non-binary context. Proponents argue that language should adapt to reflect current social realities, and that traditional rules can limit inclusive language.

2. Prescriptive Grammar: This stance upholds the historical usage of they is, emphasizing the clarity and unambiguous nature of language. Critics argue that the shift to they as a singular pronoun can be confusing in complex sentences and may lead to misunderstandings.

Personal Reflections on Inclusive Language

Many personal stories illustrate the challenge of implementing inclusive language. For instance, Roberta mentions her experience of adjusting to the use of they as a singular pronoun and the memory of a friend at university who preferred they. She reflects on the effort required to use they are consistently and recalls the friends' appreciation for the effort, regardless of occasional inaccuracies in usage.

Future of Inclusive Language

While the debate over they is remains open, many experts suggest that the language will continue to evolve. As awareness of diverse gender identities grows, so will the acceptance and use of they as a singular pronoun. However, the journey to widespread acceptance is likely to be gradual and ongoing.

To navigate this evolving landscape, it is helpful to stay informed about linguistic trends and to use language that feels respectful and inclusive to those you communicate with. Whether you choose to use they is or adhere to they are, the key is to do so consistently and with respect for the preferences of those you address.

Complementary Resources

For those interested in further reading and resources, here are a few reputable links:

Gender-Inclusive Language Guide Language Diversity and Inclusion Modern Grammar Rules

Understanding and implementing inclusive language is an important step towards creating a more respectful and inclusive society. While the debate over they is continues, it is clear that language will continue to evolve in response to the needs of a diverse and changing world.