Exploring the Comparative Reaction Speeds of Mary Watson and Sherlock Holmes

The query regarding the immense reaction speeds of Mary Watson compared to Sherlock Holmes is a thought-provoking one, often stirring debates among Warehouse 10 enthusiasts. In the episode of the BBC series Sherlock, a question arises about why Mary, known for her ninja-like skills and quick reflexes, could seemingly predict a bullet's trajectory and position herself within its path, whereas Sherlock, the brilliant detective, could not similarly leap out of harm's way. This article delves into the discrepancies in their reactions, exploring various factors that contribute to their distinct responses.

What Contributed to the Difference in Their Reactions?

The difference in their reactions can be attributed to several factors, including situational awareness, character traits, and the need for narrative tension:

Situational Awareness

Mary Watson is said to have trained like a ninja assassin, a facet that undoubtedly hones her skills and reactions. Her readiness to act instinctively to protect Sherlock is understandable given her background and the depth of her feelings for him. In contrast, Sherlock Holmes, though highly intelligent and observant, may not have anticipated the sudden threat. Based on his focused nature and the typical portrayal in the series, he appears to be more engrossed in the case at hand, reducing his situational awareness in that moment.

Character Traits

Mary is portrayed as a resourceful and protective individual, willing to put herself in harm's way for those she cares about. This is seen through her actions throughout the series where she demonstrates significant bravery, such as the moment where she shot Sherlock to protect him from a greater threat. On the other hand, Sherlock, while highly knowledgeable and keenly observant, often relies on his mind and logical reasoning rather than immediate physical action. This difference in character traits may explain why she could predict and defend against the bullet, while Sherlock could not.

Dramatic Effect

From a narrative perspective, Mary's actions serve as a powerful moment, emphasizing her bravery and the depth of her feelings for Sherlock. It creates tension and adds a layer of drama, making the scene more impactful for the audience. The sudden appearance of a potentially lethal situation in the midst of a conversation highlights the danger and the bond between the two characters.

Investigating Further: Mary's Training and Sherlock's Abilities

It is notable that Mary has been trained as a ninja assassin, a discipline known for its rigorous training in quick reflexes and the ability to jump into the path of a threat. This implies that her skillset is specifically honed for such high-stress situations. In contrast, Sherlock, despite his brilliance, does not possess this same training, which explains the disparity in their reactions.

Theories and Speculations

Several theories and speculations have arisen, especially in relation to Mary's actions in Season 4. These theories include the EMP (Extended Mind Palace) Theory and the Alibi Theory.

EMP Extended Mind Palace Theory

According to the EMP Extended Mind Palace theory, throughout Season 4, Sherlock is said to be in his mind palace still. This theory suggests that there are numerous plot holes and strange recurring moments, leading to the conclusion that Sherlock is in a coma and his mind is awake, but his body is not. This might explain why he could not anticipate and react to the bullet as quickly as Mary.

Alibi Theory

The Alibi theory posits that there is a change in the story of Season 4. This means that the scene where Mary jumps in front of the bullet may not be accurate, and it could have been altered. Theories within this framework suggest that Mary was actually the one who was shot, while John or another character shot her. Alternatively, it suggests that the scene was fabricated to maintain mystery and suspense.

It is worth noting that, in the context of the scene, the distance from which the bullet was shot (approximately 2 meters) and the speed at which bullets travel make Mary's action seem nearly impossible without specialized training, such as that of a ninja assassin.

Conclusion

The discrepancy in reactions between Mary Watson and Sherlock Holmes can be attributed to situational awareness, character traits, and narrative needs, rather than an objective measure of speed or reflexes. Mary's training as a ninja assassin undoubtedly gives her the edge in reacting decisively to a threat, while Sherlock's reliance on his logical and observational skills might make him less prepared for such immediate physical confrontations.

While theories such as the EMP and Alibi theories seek to provide alternative explanations for why Mary was able to jump in front of the bullet, the core discussion centers on the practical and narrative reasons behind their different responses in the situation depicted.